These to and fro discussions are worth looking at again:
(A couple of the links here are broken. This is Hirsh’s piece against the academic boycott in Democratiya 13. This is the response and discussion in Democratiya 14)
About Engage
Sign up
Archives
Posts by date
Categories
- academics (151)
- analogy – apartheid/Israel (38)
- analogy – Holocaust/Israel (37)
- anti-racism (47)
- anti-Zionism (142)
- antisemitism (320)
- anti-racist antisemitism (62)
- antisemitism denial (36)
- Jewish antisemitism (17)
- open antisemitism (40)
- street antisemitism (19)
- art (21)
- as-a-Jew (37)
- book (7)
- boycott divestment & sanctions (204)
- academic boycott (98)
- boycott opposition (44)
- silent boycott (1)
- sporting boycott (2)
- bridges (1)
- campus activism (38)
- cartoons (5)
- child killing (8)
- coexistence (24)
- conflict (37)
- conflict resolution (20)
- conspiracy beliefs (35)
- event (22)
- free expression (36)
- Gaza (27)
- Hamas (18)
- Holocaust (57)
- denial (21)
- Holocaust comparisons (16)
- humour (1)
- intelligentsia (13)
- Iran (21)
- Israel (72)
- Jews as proxy Israelis (25)
- law (10)
- letter (13)
- media (42)
- British media (29)
- national identity (14)
- neo-nazi (8)
- Palestinians (34)
- peace activism (23)
- religion (3)
- suppression (17)
- The Left (94)
- SWP (12)
- The Right (30)
- trade union (100)
- UCU (74)
- Uncategorized (628)
- United Nations (12)
Admin
David Hirsh, Seumas Milne and Martin Shaw
February 2, 2010 — David Hirsh
Posted in Uncategorized. 2 Comments »
2 Responses to “David Hirsh, Seumas Milne and Martin Shaw”
Leave a reply to Absolute Observer Cancel reply
Search
Subscribe
-
Recent posts
- Labour needs to show the electorate who it is now
- Denial of antisemitism and intolerance of ambiguity – Tanja Ehmann
- Yaron Matras: The story of Hugh, or why I’ve joined the London Centre for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism
- Is trying to “replace” Israel with a democratic state antisemitic? A response to Peter Beinart by David Hirsh
- Crowdfunding appeal, by James Mendelsohn
- Tricia Roth z”l – by David Hirsh
- Corbynites: once you start with antisemitism, you build a whole new reality in which anything is possible; that’s why we’re afraid of you – David Hirsh
- The “Israel is a racist endeavour” clause in the IHRA definition – David Hirsh
- The JDA Definition of Antisemitism is Completely Incoherent and Much Worse than the IHRA Definition – Ari Allyn-Feuer
- Jewish and Israel Studies scholars demand the right to spend donors’ money on legitimizing antizionism
Recent comments
- David Hirsh on Words of ambivalence for Holocaust Memorial Day at Goldsmiths, University of London – David Hirsh
- Jonathan on Sheffield Hallam University has an antisemitism problem – David Hirsh
- Camila Bassi on Sheffield Hallam UCU says David Miller was a victim of “malicious and unfounded allegations” of antisemitism
- | Tony Greenstein on The Myth of the Institutional Boycott – Jon Pike
- STAN NADEL on Useful links about the “Jerusalem Declaration”
- David Hirsh on Useful links about the “Jerusalem Declaration”
- STAN NADEL on Useful links about the “Jerusalem Declaration”
- thenodster on The IHRA definition is a material social fact – David Hirsh
- Richard Jankel on The IHRA definition is a material social fact – David Hirsh
- Chip Berlet on Some links relating to the IHRA definition of antisemitism – David Hirsh
Engage on Twitter
Tweets by engageonline-
Academic
- Brandeis Center
- European Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism
- European Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism
- Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism, Indiana University
- Journal for the Study of Antisemitism
- Pears Institute for the Study of Antisemitism
- Stephen Roth Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism and Racism
- The Vidal Sassoon International Center for the Study of Antisemitism
Blogroll
- Alliance for Workers' Liberty
- Bob From Brockley
- European Forum on Antisemitism
- Givat Haviva
- Harry's Place
- Ignoblus
- It's Complicated
- MERETZ UK
- Modernityblog
- Mystical Politics
- Normblog
- Obliged to Offend
- Peace Now UK
- Point of No Return
- Scholars for Peace in the Middle East
- The Community Security Trust blog
- Trade Unions Linking Israel and Palestine
Peace and coexistence
Top Posts
- Why Israel stops when the siren sounds - David Hirsh
- The Livingstone Formulation - David Hirsh
- Ken Stern isn't the only author the IHRA working definition of antisemitism
- Yaron Matras: The story of Hugh, or why I’ve joined the London Centre for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism
- From Fathom: Antisemitism and Oren Ben-Dor
- The Abuse of Holocaust Memory: The Far Right, the Far Left and the Middle East – Michael Ezra Issue 4 - Engage Journal - February 2007
- If I say "Zionist" not "Jew" then I can't be antisemitic, can I? - Dave Rich - 15 September 2006
- In response to attempts to cancel Israeli Science Day
- Tali Shalom-Ezer won't do Ken Loach's work for him
- Shame about The Pixies
Engage 
February 2, 2010 at 7:05 pm
the david hirsch CiF, in retrospect to what has actually occured and the unraveling of the facts about Israel’s aggression, is rather nauseating in its knee-jerk defense of Israel’s propaganda campaign. Why bother even to pick it apart it is filled with so many shallow platitudes.
February 3, 2010 at 10:30 am
Tell you what aradi, when you have finsihed throwing up, perhaps you could take the time to “pick apart the shallow platitudes,” because at the moment you have said nothing that distinguishes you from the obsessive trols that come here every now and then. Go on, I dare you, do some work.