from talking squid
About Engage
Sign up
Archives
Posts by date
Categories
- academics (151)
- analogy – apartheid/Israel (38)
- analogy – Holocaust/Israel (37)
- anti-racism (47)
- anti-Zionism (142)
- antisemitism (320)
- anti-racist antisemitism (62)
- antisemitism denial (36)
- Jewish antisemitism (17)
- open antisemitism (40)
- street antisemitism (19)
- art (21)
- as-a-Jew (37)
- book (7)
- boycott divestment & sanctions (204)
- academic boycott (98)
- boycott opposition (44)
- silent boycott (1)
- sporting boycott (2)
- bridges (1)
- campus activism (38)
- cartoons (5)
- child killing (8)
- coexistence (24)
- conflict (37)
- conflict resolution (20)
- conspiracy beliefs (35)
- event (22)
- free expression (36)
- Gaza (27)
- Hamas (18)
- Holocaust (57)
- denial (21)
- Holocaust comparisons (16)
- humour (1)
- intelligentsia (13)
- Iran (21)
- Israel (72)
- Jews as proxy Israelis (25)
- law (10)
- letter (13)
- media (42)
- British media (29)
- national identity (14)
- neo-nazi (8)
- Palestinians (34)
- peace activism (23)
- religion (3)
- suppression (17)
- The Left (94)
- SWP (12)
- The Right (30)
- trade union (100)
- UCU (74)
- Uncategorized (628)
- United Nations (12)
Admin
Are you antisemtic? – From Talking Squid
June 3, 2011 — David Hirsh3 Responses to “Are you antisemtic? – From Talking Squid”
Leave a comment Cancel reply
Search
Subscribe
-
Recent posts
- Labour needs to show the electorate who it is now
- Denial of antisemitism and intolerance of ambiguity – Tanja Ehmann
- Yaron Matras: The story of Hugh, or why I’ve joined the London Centre for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism
- Is trying to “replace” Israel with a democratic state antisemitic? A response to Peter Beinart by David Hirsh
- Crowdfunding appeal, by James Mendelsohn
- Tricia Roth z”l – by David Hirsh
- Corbynites: once you start with antisemitism, you build a whole new reality in which anything is possible; that’s why we’re afraid of you – David Hirsh
- The “Israel is a racist endeavour” clause in the IHRA definition – David Hirsh
- The JDA Definition of Antisemitism is Completely Incoherent and Much Worse than the IHRA Definition – Ari Allyn-Feuer
- Jewish and Israel Studies scholars demand the right to spend donors’ money on legitimizing antizionism
Recent comments
- David Hirsh on Words of ambivalence for Holocaust Memorial Day at Goldsmiths, University of London – David Hirsh
- Jonathan on Sheffield Hallam University has an antisemitism problem – David Hirsh
- Camila Bassi on Sheffield Hallam UCU says David Miller was a victim of “malicious and unfounded allegations” of antisemitism
- | Tony Greenstein on The Myth of the Institutional Boycott – Jon Pike
- STAN NADEL on Useful links about the “Jerusalem Declaration”
- David Hirsh on Useful links about the “Jerusalem Declaration”
- STAN NADEL on Useful links about the “Jerusalem Declaration”
- thenodster on The IHRA definition is a material social fact – David Hirsh
- Richard Jankel on The IHRA definition is a material social fact – David Hirsh
- Chip Berlet on Some links relating to the IHRA definition of antisemitism – David Hirsh
Engage on Twitter
Tweets by engageonline-
Academic
- Brandeis Center
- European Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism
- European Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism
- Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism, Indiana University
- Journal for the Study of Antisemitism
- Pears Institute for the Study of Antisemitism
- Stephen Roth Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism and Racism
- The Vidal Sassoon International Center for the Study of Antisemitism
Blogroll
- Alliance for Workers' Liberty
- Bob From Brockley
- European Forum on Antisemitism
- Givat Haviva
- Harry's Place
- Ignoblus
- It's Complicated
- MERETZ UK
- Modernityblog
- Mystical Politics
- Normblog
- Obliged to Offend
- Peace Now UK
- Point of No Return
- Scholars for Peace in the Middle East
- The Community Security Trust blog
- Trade Unions Linking Israel and Palestine
Peace and coexistence
Top Posts
- Naomi Klein is wrong to call for a boycott of Israel - David Hirsh
- Some links relating to the IHRA definition of antisemitism - David Hirsh
- Useful links about the "Jerusalem Declaration"
- The Livingstone Formulation - David Hirsh
- David Hirsh in debate with Ilan Pappé, Nadia Naser-Najjab, Alan Johnson
- The "Israel is a racist endeavour" clause in the IHRA definition - David Hirsh
- No reason to boycott Israel, says director Wim Wenders.
- Tricia Roth z”l - by David Hirsh
- Crowdfunding appeal, by James Mendelsohn
- Accusations of the Israeli occupation of Hungary
Engage 
June 3, 2011 at 6:08 pm
This is very complicated. I think the UCU could come up with a simpler one:
(1) Do you identify as “left”?
Yes: Congratulations, you’re not anti-Semitic!
No: (2) Does your hostility to Jews include hostility to Israel?
Yes: Congratulations, you’re an honorary part of the “global left”, and not anti-Semitic!
No: You might be anti-Semitic. Or might not. With no link to Israel, I suddenly find myself bored about this conversation.
June 5, 2011 at 1:34 pm
You’re both right.
June 6, 2011 at 4:31 pm
I think the flow chart is brilliant and will share with friends.